Lenders and Valuers

A below-threshold commercial asset is a non-green asset — and as lenders publish GAR targets, non-green collateral becomes harder to hold and harder to price competitively.

Lender reviewing loan book green asset ratio calculations

Green Asset Ratio (GAR) measures the proportion of a lender's assets that are aligned with the EU Taxonomy. For real estate lending, Taxonomy alignment requires the collateral property to meet specified energy performance criteria — principally EPC threshold requirements.

A commercial building below the Taxonomy EPC threshold is a non-green asset. Every non-green asset held as collateral suppresses the lender's GAR. As lenders publish GAR targets and are required to disclose GAR trajectories, below-threshold collateral becomes progressively harder to hold at competitive terms — and progressively more expensive to manage when it appears in portfolio-level ESG reporting.

Primary source — EBA lender obligations on ESG risk in real estate lending: EBA Guidelines on loan origination and monitoring, EBA/GL/2020/06, published 29 May 2020, applicable from 30 June 2021. Paragraph 57 requires institutions to incorporate ESG factors into credit risk policies and procedures. Paragraph 208, under the valuation of immovable property collateral section, states explicitly that "institutions should take into account ESG factors affecting the value of the collateral, for example, the energy efficiency of buildings." This is the operative requirement that makes EPC rating a mandatory consideration in commercial real estate collateral assessment.

Source: EBA/GL/2020/06, eba.europa.eu. Verified: 29 Aug 2026.

The trajectory — why this gets harder over time, not easier

Below-threshold assets do not stay at a fixed GAR drag. Three compounding factors increase the pressure over time:

More lenders publishing GAR targets — as non-financial corporates and banks publish Taxonomy-aligned commitments, the pressure to demonstrate GAR improvement creates internal pressure on origination teams to avoid non-qualifying assets. A below-threshold asset that was acceptable collateral two years ago may now be at the margin.

Compliance deadlines approaching — as the 2031 and 2033 deadlines approach, the market discount on below-threshold assets deepens (see Stage 1 data). The LTV implication of a widening brown discount on existing security is a monitoring requirement, not only an origination consideration.

Secondary market liquidity — below-threshold commercial real estate is progressively less attractive in the secondary loan market, where buyers apply their own ESG criteria. A lender holding below-threshold collateral that it wishes to sell or securitise faces a narrower buyer pool.

What lenders can and should require of borrowers

EPC improvement covenants convert a compliance risk into a managed exposure. Three covenant structures in use in the market:

EPC improvement covenant — the borrower commits to achieving a specified EPC rating by a specified date as a condition of the loan. Non-compliance with the covenant triggers a review event, which may include margin increase, LTV adjustment, or acceleration, depending on the facility terms.

Improvement plan commitment — the borrower submits an EPC improvement plan (with consultant sign-off) within a specified period of drawdown. The plan becomes a condition precedent to the next drawdown tranche or the first review date.

Milestone-linked drawdown — tranches of the facility are released against confirmed EPC milestones. This structure is appropriate for new-build or major refurbishment where EPC progression can be measured against the programme.

The non-obvious case for requiring covenants: the lender who requires an EPC improvement covenant at origination protects three things simultaneously — the GAR of the facility, the credit quality of the security as compliance deadlines approach, and the ability to sell or securitise the loan to a buyer with their own EPC requirements. A lender who does not require the covenant inherits those risks without the mitigation.

Partial upgrade LTV risk — the most commonly missed exposure

When a borrower upgrades one asset in a cross-collateralised portfolio, the lender typically reassesses the entire portfolio. The upgraded asset receives a green premium. Non-upgraded assets are simultaneously reassessed at a brown discount — because the market now contains more certified compliant stock against which they are compared.

The practical result: a borrower who upgrades property A expecting to free headroom for property B may find that B has been marked down in the same review, tightening overall LTV across the facility. The lender who has not anticipated this dynamic is surprised by a covenant squeeze that the borrower did not intend to trigger.

For lenders with cross-collateralised facilities on mixed-rating portfolios, this is a monitoring item, not only an origination item. The correct mitigation from the borrower's perspective is a whole-estate upgrade programme that addresses all assets before triggering a formal revaluation.

Source: Savills green premium/brown discount analysis 2025; IPF EPC yield differentials. Verified: 29 Aug 2026.

Practical EPC assessment for a loan book

Estimating EPC distribution across a commercial real estate portfolio without full property-level data:

By asset type — industrial and warehouse assets tend to have lower base energy intensity than office and retail; their compliance gap is typically smaller. Multi-tenanted offices and retail assets with complex services have the largest typical gaps. Heritage assets are structurally constrained in what fabric improvement is achievable.

By age — buildings constructed before 1990 before widespread energy efficiency requirements carry the highest structural exposure. Post-2010 construction is typically closer to threshold.

By tenure — owner-occupied buildings carry less compliance urgency (they are not subject to the private rented non-domestic requirement in the UK until they seek to let). Multi-tenanted buildings are subject to MEES requirements at the point of letting.

The register check — the Non-Domestic EPC register for England and Wales (find-energy-certificate.service.gov.uk) is searchable by address and returns the current rating, certificate date, and floor area. For a portfolio of 20–50 assets, a desk review of the register produces a material exposure map before any site visit.

Stage 3 of 4

Portfolio-level EPC risk assessment

How to assess EPC exposure across a loan book — and what it produces in credit risk assessment and provisioning.

Portfolio EPC risk